Similar to: Chicago Metallic 44615 Pullman Bread Loaf Pan

Top Picks

Chicago Metallic 44615 Pullman Bread Loaf Pan
Top Pick

Best heavy duty pan for bakers wanting professional square sandwich loaves.

This is the workhorse you need for consistent, bakery-style sandwich loaves with perfectly square edges. The heavy-duty steel construction guarantees even browning, while the slick, PFOA-free coating ensures your bread slides out effortlessly every time. It’s a specialized tool, but for anyone serious about homemade sandwich bread, it’s indispensable.

Durable Steel

Warp Prevention

Non-Stick

Less Oil

Chicago Metallic Commercial II Pullman Loaf Pan
Runner-Up

Best professional-grade tool for bakers seeking perfectly shaped, uniform sandwich loaves.

This is the gold standard for achieving that elusive, perfectly square bakery loaf at home. The heavy-duty steel construction and sliding lid guarantee a uniform crumb, though you’ll have to commit to a specific loaf size to get those professional results.

Even Baking

Nonstick Coating

Durable Rim

Standard Loaf

Best choice for home bakers crafting uniform, square-shaped sandwich loaves.

This is the gold standard for achieving that elusive, perfectly square sandwich loaf at home. By trapping steam with a sliding lid, it forces a dense, uniform crumb and a soft crust, though you sacrifice the rustic, domed aesthetic of a traditional open-top bake.

Square Loaves

Easy Release

Durable Steel

Golden Crust

Best professional grade tool for bakers wanting uniform sandwich bread slices.

Best Pullman pan for home bakers seeking professional, square-shaped loaves.

Best sandwich loaf pan for home bakers seeking professional, uniform results.

Best rectangular mold for bakers crafting uniform sandwich loaves at home.